PipOwO finally finished... Sonic Adventure
Way past cool.
Depending on what your age is right now, there's a chance you have heard the phrase "Sonic had a rough transition to 3D". This phrase was particularly prominent during what many called "Sonic Dark Era" which started with Sonic the Hedgehog until probably Sonic Frontiers. During this time, Sonic was the laughing stock of the rest of fandoms, and this specific phrase was repeated ad nauseum to say how the series hasn't been good since the Dreamcast.
This has always caught my attention, because when I look back, the Sonic fanbase don't see Sonic Adventure in a such negative way, quite the opposite actually. They have a very special kind of love for everything it brought to the series, in the form of characters, both new and returning with the purpose to profundize on them more, as well as a more interesting world in which all stories will be told. The importance this game has is something I always felt it opposed that notion.
And such the best way to understand who was right was obviously playing (it's not like I'm a Twitter ragebaiter) and after finishing all the stories, I can say that Sonic didn't have a rough transition to 3D, but it did have a very ambitious one, leaving as a result a weird game with a lot of passion put into it.
Sonic Adventure is a 3D platformer video game in the Sonic the Hedgehog series. The player can control six characters from the Sonic universe, each with their own gameplay and point of view of the story. The game is divided up into two types of levels: Action Stages and Adventure Fields. The division of Action Stages and Adventure Fields are a serious departure from all previous Sonic games. Adventure Fields are non-linear game stages that contain very few items, generally designed for puzzle solving, exploration and plot advancement. Action Stages are more speed based and have Rings scattered in them. Sonic Adventure was the top-selling Dreamcast game and received a sequel in 2001, marking the 10th anniversary of the Sonic the Hedgehog series.
For being the first full-lenght 3D Sonic game (aside from Sonic 3D Blast™, Sonic Jam and Sonic the Fighters) they really jump straight into the abyss. They decided that it wouldn't be just about the titular character, they would include another five, two of these being brand new ones, each having unique gameplay gimmicks and different story perspectives that end up connecting with each other.
Not only they wanted to do something much more ambitious in the narrative that doesn't look like anything from the Sonic franchise until then, but also in gameplay, by wanting to somehow fit six distinct styles in the same level designs.
Sonic's story is what can be said as the "main one", being the longest and definitely the most polished of them all. I can confidently say the controls were actually very fun (aside from some "technical issues" I will talk later). They managed to translate really well the speed of Sonic without feeling uncontrolable, and it helps that the level design has speed as a priority. Tails and Amy don't deviate to much from him, although their levels are more based on races and escaping respectively, with their own special movements.

The rest are a lot more unique, Knuckles has to find the Master Emerald pieces in every level using a radar, totally diferent from the others. But the last two I have no idea why are they here. Big throws everything out the window and is a fishing minigame of five levels, a very bad one at that, and E102 "Gamma" is a "Search and Destroy" where you need to reach a boss in time and defeat it.
Taking into account that this was their first full-lenght 3D game, it's impossible to deny that what they wanted to make was extremely ambitious and, even if in some parts like Sonic story there was a positive result, in general many of these ideas feel rough and at some point restricted.
It could be contained in a very simple story that doesn't allow any expansion to the mythology of this world, more convoluted controls that it should have, a primitive camera or technical hiccups, all of these end up taking away from the whole experience.
I can't deny that Sonic Adventure is quite the special game, It was at this point when the character of Sonic and the whole franchise really became what it is, even with all the problem it has, largely due to the technical and experience limitations they had at the time.

At first glance this is a quite simple game when we see it from afar, due to its straightfoward narrative and rudimentary technical aspects, but when you see it closely, you can see how ambitious the game really is, and at some point ahead of its time, because Mario and other platformers would take awhile to try something similar to Sonic Adventure.
Now, there was something I kept thinking while I was playing, and keep thinking about it after that, and thats the possibility of a remake. Sonic fans have been asking for it for years at this point, and while the Sonic Team boss has said there wouldn't be one in favor of new experiences, the idea is still there.
Here's the thing, I believe a remake could fix a lot of the problems that were caused by lack of experience on this new way of making games, and aspects like the different stories with distinct mechanics and the mythology they built would shine a lot more. However, part of the affection I have for Sonic Adventure is because of that jankiness. The facial animations, abrupt cuts in the music and awkward cutscenes, add something really unique and special to everything, even if it wasn't really intented as part of its identity.
So, if a remakes ends up being made, it wouldn't really upset me as it would allow it to shine with more intensity, because there's something really special here, but obviously, this would mean we would lose part of its identity and the proof of how Sonic, even with everything he has, did have a good transition to 3D.

Played on PC via Steam
PipOwO is mixed on Sonic Adventure
“While it's janky and truly a product of its time, it has aged a lot more gracefully than a lot of people say it does, being very ahead of its time with many interesting ideas.”
This is a translation from my review on V-Unik Blog.

