Skip to main content
player.gg

PipOwO finally finished... LIVE A LIVE

In shadow guides his kin...

PipOwO

During 1994, Squaresoft released LIVE A LIVE for the Super Famicom, an RPG directed by Takashi Tokita as his first directorial role. Takashi was already very familiar to this genre, having been inspired by Dragon Warrior II , and later on working on games like The Final Fantasy Legend and Final Fantasy IV , however for his debut as a director, he would make something that didn't look to replicate anything from those two series, and instead would create something totally new.

LIVE A LIVE stands out for many things, like the combat system, basing it on a grid, or by being the first Square game that features Yoko Shimomura music, but above all of that, it has the peculiarity of being an anthology, where each chapter places you on a different era, with different characters and, most importantly, distict mechanics. This put the game on the spotlight as one of the most interesting RPGs ever made, even if it got a poor commercial reception, but sadly it never got out of Japan in its original version, at least until 2022.

During a Nintendo Direct, it was announced that it would finally release overseas in the form of a remake made by Team Asano and Historia. I was already aware of LIVE A LIVE as one of those "games that never came out of Japan" fun-facts and also because of the connection it has with Undertale and MEGALOVANIA, so I was very interested into finally seeing first-hand why this title was so requested by a lot of people, and finally after 3+ years, I finished it.

LIVE A LIVE
Square Enix, historia Inc.

The legend is alive! LIVE A LIVE, originally only released for the Super Famicom in Japan, is being revived on Steam! Experience this legendary RPG, brought alive in the same HD-2D visual style as OCTOPATH TRAVELER.

AdventureRPGRole-playing (RPG)

SUCH HIGH EXPECTATIONS...

I'm going to be very honest, my expectations for LIVE A LIVE weren't the correct ones, even if I'm not really sure of what I was looking for. I knew it was a niche RPG known as a game that didn't get out of Japan and nothing more, so when I started it and I realized it was very different to any other RPG I felt pretty confused, which led to me taking a lot to not only finish it, but also to understand the game under it's own terms.

As I've already said in the beginning, this is an anthology that uses the RPG genre as a base to tell their nine stories, each one taking place on a different time period, like the Wild West, Imperial China, Distant Future or the Present, and because of that each one exist on their own bubble, with very little (or straight up none) connections to the others. It is a good idea, one that they manage to execute succesfully by the end, although some stories vary in quality.

LIVE A LIVE eventually would serve as an inspiration for multiple titles, with the most notorious and the one that could be considered its spiritual succesor, being Octopath Traveler, which is also an anthology with eight stories, although these ones happen at the same time. I've already written a review about this game, but in relation to this matter, there are so many things that it should've taken from LIVE A LIVE for a better result, especially by the end

imagen.png

MEGALOMANIA

Alongside how each story is separated by narrative, they also differenciate themselves (in major or minor ways) by their gameplay. Everyone keeps the same combat based on a grid where the position and orientation is really important during every fight, leaving as a result a loop, maybe a bit simple, but in cases as the Edo Era you can feel the deepness this system can archive.

Outside of this, each chapter has at least something that changes the pre-established rules of what can be an RPG. The Twilight of Edo Japan, Imperial China, the Prehistory, the Near Future and the Middle Ages get closer to that, but they still have certain peculiarities, such as the Prehistory having zero dialogues, while, for example, the Distant Future has almost to no combat, the Wild West asking you to place traps before the sun comes up, and the Present being similar to a fighting game Arcade mode.

imagen.png

It is a really interesting idea and sets it apart from the rest of titles, however, by doing it this way, it leads to some stories feel more developed than others. The Present, the one I started with, is very short, lasting about two or less hours and feels more like a demo or a proof of concept, or the Wild West, leaving a sensation that it could have been a lot more gameplay-wise. Although I have to say, even if this format didn't click for me in the moment, by the time I got to the final story, I finally understood it and ended up apreciating a lot more the way that they did it, but I will go deeper on that later.

CONTAINED BEAUTY

Because this is a remake, the visual and sound aspects change a lot compared to the Super Famicom version, using this time the HD-2D style that has caracterized Team Asano since the launch of OCTOPATH TRAVELER™, but in a more contained way. I don't really know how to explain it, but when you compare them you can see some differences in the way they use the lightning, camera work and the details in the backgrounds.

LIVEALIVECOMP.png

However, even with that LIVE A LIVE doesn't lets down in the most important moments in terms of spectacle, and takes advantage of the tech upgrade to add a lot more dynamisim to certain scenes. This helps a lot to make the final fights look incredlble, especially the ones from the Near Future and the Twilight of Edo Japan, and when you add the remade soundtrack made by Yoko Shimomura (mainly MEGALOMANIA as the boss theme) you get something that slowly makes you engaged as a result, and makes you excited to reach the end, to discover how everything clicks together.

As you progress through it, even if each story is separate from each other, you realize there's something that links them, the word Odio and its meaning, defining every final boss until now. Without spoiling too much because the end result is quite surprising, there is a common enemy to every protagonist, with a finale that wraps LIVE A LIVE theme particularly well. It's not very deep, but the message of how anyone can let hate take the best of them, but we should keep fighting agaisnt it when it shows up, did get me after finishing the game and because of the actual global climate.

VEREDICT

At the time I'm finishing this review and I've let my feelings towards LIVE A LIVE sink in, I have been slowly realizing that I liked it more than I had in mind. It is not perfect, and although the execution had success by end, it doesn't remove that certain sections felt less developed and with a lot of untapped potential, both in narrative and in mechanics.

Its clear that some of this comes from the original version, the limitations of the Super Famicom led to that every idea couldn't be fully realized, and the remake is faithful to what they achieved in that moment. But even with that, LIVE A LIVE is a really interesting and special game that deserves a bigger audience for what it wanted to do, even if some of its contemporaries ended up doing it better.

imagen.png

PipOwO really enjoyed LIVE A LIVE

7.6

“While some ideas aren't fully taken advantage from, the sheer creativity and craftmanship that permeates every minute of this game, makes it one of the most interesting RPGs of the Super Famicom era, even in remake form.”

+Creative concept+Great soundtrack+Satisfying gameplay+Stunning graphics−Lack of content
Loading comments